SMPTE
AG
19
Administrative
Guideline
Project
Status
Values
Approved:
2023-03-21
Copyright
Β©
2023
,
Society
of
Motion
Picture
and
Television
Engineers
.
All
rights
reserved.
No
part
of
this
material
may
be
reproduced,
by
any
means
whatsoever,
without
the
prior
written
permission
of
the
Society
of
Motion
Picture
and
Television
Engineers.
Foreword
π
The
Society
of
Motion
Picture
and
Television
Engineers
(SMPTE)
is
an
internationally-recognized
standards
developing
organization.
Headquartered
and
incorporated
in
the
United
States
of
America,
SMPTE
has
members
in
over
80
countries
on
six
continents.
SMPTEβs
Engineering
Documents,
including
Standards,
Recommended
Practices,
and
Engineering
Guidelines,
are
prepared
by
SMPTEβs
Technology
Committees.
Participation
in
these
Committees
is
open
to
all
with
a
bona
fide
interest
in
their
work.
SMPTE
cooperates
closely
with
other
standards-developing
organizations,
including
ISO,
IEC
and
ITU.
SMPTE
Engineering
Documents
are
drafted
in
accordance
with
the
rules
given
in
its
Standards
Operations
Manual.
For
more
information,
please
visit
www.smpte.org
.
This
Standards
Administrative
Guideline
forms
an
adjunct
to
the
use
and
interpretation
of
the
SMPTE
Standards
Operations
Manual.
In
the
event
of
a
conflict,
the
Operations
Manual
shall
prevail.
This
Administrative
Guideline
describes
the
tracking
of
project
completion
so
that
consistent
progress
can
be
measured
between
projects,
between
document
types
and
between
TCs
This
Administrative
Guideline
is
intended
to
help
manage
SMPTE
Projects.
3
Normative
references
π
The
following
documents
are
referred
to
in
the
text
in
such
a
way
that
some
or
all
of
their
content
constitutes
requirements
of
this
document.
For
dated
references,
only
the
edition
cited
applies.
For
undated
references,
the
latest
edition
of
the
referenced
document
(including
any
amendments)
applies.
4
Terms
and
definitions
π
For
the
purposes
of
this
document,
the
terms
and
definitions
given
in
the
following
documents
apply:
5
Projects
π
General
rules
for
Projects:
-
For
every
SMPTE
document
being
worked
on,
there
should
be
a
SMPTE
Project
associated
with
that
document
-
Work
that
requires
multiple
documents
should
have
a
parent
project
that
references
all
child
projects
for
the
documents
being
worked
on.
TC
Chairs
may
rule
that
a
parent
project
is
not
needed.
-
At
the
discretion
of
the
Technology
Committee,
a
Sub
Group
may
be
allocated
one
or
more
projects
(see
SMPTE
Standards
Operations
Manual
).
6
Project
Completion
States
π
6.1
Overview
π
The
states
given
below
relate
to
the
definition
of
the
document
states
for
different
document
types
in
the
SMPTE
Standards
Operations
Manual
or
in
SMPTE
AG-22
.
The
trigger(s)
for
transition
to
another
state
are
given
in
italics
in
parenthesis.
NOTE
1
ββ
In
all
cases,
the
project
chair
is
responsible
for
updating
the
project
completion
state
where
the
state
less
than
or
equal
to
90%.
HQ
updates
the
state
above
90%.
NOTE
2
ββ
DP
vote
comments
and
ST
Audit
comments
are
actually
late
comments
on
an
FCD
ballot
and
the
Project
Chair
should
determine
the
status
according
to
whether
such
comments
are
to
be
addressed
or
deferred
according
to
the
SMPTE
Standards
Operations
Manual
.
6.2
Project
States
for
ST,
RP
&
EG
documents
π
-
0%
-
Project
not
approved
(then
project
gets
objections
or
is
approved)
-
5%
-
Project
awaiting
ST
objection
disposition
vote
(then
project
is
approved
or
cancelled)
-
10%
-
Project
approved
(then
a
document
is
created)
-
20%
-
WG
or
DG
working
on
WD
document
(then
WD
is
elevated
to
the
TC)
-
25%
-
TC
has
WD
document
(then
document
starts
pre-FCD
review)
-
30%
-
WD
to
CD
process
i.e.
pre-FCD
review
&
register
submission
(then
document
ready
for
FCD
ballot)
-
40%
-
CD
awaiting
FCD
ballot
(then
FCD
ballot
starts)
-
50%
-
FCD
ballot
in
progress
(then
FCD
ballot
ends)
-
60%
-
FCD
ballot
comment
resolution
(then
pre-DP
vote
starts
or
ST
audit
starts)
-
70%
-
pre-DP
review
(then
DP
vote
starts)
-
80%
-
DP
vote
(then
ST
Audit
package
delivered
to
HQ)
-
90%
-
ST
Audit
(then
document
sent
for
publishing)
-
95%
-
document
in
HQ
(then
document
appears
in
store)
-
100%
-
published
&
document
uploaded
to
TC
Ref
Docs
6.3
Project
States
for
RDD
documents
π
-
0%
-
Project
not
approved
(then
project
gets
objections
or
is
approved)
-
5%
-
Project
awaiting
ST
objection
disposition
vote
(then
project
is
approved
or
cancelled)
-
10%
-
Project
approved
(then
a
document
is
created)
-
20%
-
WG
or
DG
working
on
WD
document
(then
WD
is
elevated
to
the
TC)
-
25%
-
TC
has
WD
document
(then
document
starts
pre-FCD
review)
-
30%
-
WD
to
CD
process
i.e.
pre-ballot
review
&
register
submission
(then
document
ready
for
RDD
ballot)
-
40%
-
CD
awaiting
RDD
ballot
(then
RDD
ballot
starts)
-
50%
-
RDD
ballot
in
progress
(then
RDD
ballot
ends)
-
60%
-
RDD
ballot
comment
resolution
(then
ST
Audit
package
delivered
to
HQ)
-
90%
-
ST
Audit
(then
document
sent
for
publishing)
-
95%
-
document
in
HQ
(then
document
appears
in
store)
-
100%
-
published
&
document
uploaded
to
TC
Ref
Docs
6.4
Project
States
for
ER
documents
π
-
0%
-
Project
not
approved
(then
project
gets
objections
or
is
approved)
-
5%
-
Project
awaiting
ST
objection
disposition
vote
(then
project
is
approved
or
cancelled)
-
10%
-
Project
approved
(then
a
document
is
created)
-
20%
-
WG
or
DG
working
on
WD
document
(then
WD
is
elevated
to
the
TC)
-
25%
-
TC
has
WD
document
(then
document
starts
pre-FCD
review)
-
30%
-
WD
to
CD
process
i.e.
TC
review
(then
document
ready
for
SVP
review)
-
40%
-
CD
awaiting
submission
to
SVP
(then
submitted
to
SVP)
-
80%
-
SVP
review
(then
sent
to
HQ
or
returned
to
TC)
-
95%
-
document
in
HQ
(then
document
appears
in
store)
-
100%
-
published
&
document
uploaded
to
TC
Ref
Docs
6.5
Project
States
for
TSP
documents
π
-
0%
-
Project
not
approved
(then
project
gets
objections
or
is
approved)
-
5%
-
Project
awaiting
ST
objection
disposition
vote
(then
project
is
approved
or
cancelled)
-
10%
-
Project
approved
(then
a
document
is
created)
-
20%
-
WG
or
DG
working
on
WD
document
(then
WD
is
elevated
to
the
TC)
-
25%
-
TC
has
WD
document
(then
document
starts
pre-FCD
review)
-
30%
-
WD
to
CD
process
i.e.
pre-FCD
review
&
register
submission
(then
document
ready
for
SVP
review)
-
40%
-
CD
awaiting
submission
to
SVP
(then
submitted
to
SVP)
-
80%
-
SVP
review
(then
sent
to
HQ
or
returned
to
TC)
-
95%
-
document
in
HQ
(then
document
appears
on
web)
-
100%
-
published
&
document
uploaded
to
TC
Ref
Docs