SMPTE AG 19
Administrative Guideline
Project Status Values
Approved: 2023-03-21
Copyright Β© 2023,
Society of Motion Picture and Television Engineers.
All rights reserved. No part of this material may be reproduced, by any means whatsoever,
without the prior written permission of the Society of Motion Picture and Television Engineers.
The Society of Motion Picture and Television Engineers (SMPTE) is an
internationally-recognized standards developing organization. Headquartered
and incorporated in the United States of America, SMPTE has members in over
80 countries on six continents. SMPTEβs Engineering Documents, including
Standards, Recommended Practices, and Engineering Guidelines, are prepared
by SMPTEβs Technology Committees. Participation in these Committees is open
to all with a bona fide interest in their work. SMPTE cooperates closely
with other standards-developing organizations, including ISO, IEC and ITU.
SMPTE Engineering Documents are drafted in accordance with the rules given
in its Standards Operations Manual.
For more information, please visit
www.smpte.org.
This Standards Administrative Guideline forms an adjunct to the use and
interpretation of the SMPTE Standards Operations Manual. In the event of a
conflict, the Operations Manual shall prevail.
This Administrative Guideline describes the tracking of project completion so that consistent progress can be measured between projects, between document types and between TCs
This Administrative Guideline is intended to help manage SMPTE Projects.
3 Normative referencesπ
The following documents are referred to in the text in such a way that some or all of
their content constitutes requirements of this document. For dated references, only the edition cited
applies. For undated references, the latest edition of the referenced document
(including any amendments) applies.
4 Terms and definitionsπ
For the purposes of this document, the terms and definitions given in the following documents apply:
5 Projectsπ
General rules for Projects:
- For every SMPTE document being worked on, there should be a SMPTE Project associated with that document
- Work that requires multiple documents should have a parent project that references all child projects for the documents being worked on. TC Chairs may rule that a parent project is not needed.
- At the discretion of the Technology Committee, a Sub Group may be allocated one or more projects (see SMPTE Standards Operations Manual).
6 Project Completion Statesπ
6.1 Overviewπ
The states given below relate to the definition of the document states for different document types in the SMPTE Standards Operations Manual or in SMPTE AG-22. The trigger(s) for transition to another state are given in italics in parenthesis.
NOTE 1 ββ In all cases, the project chair is responsible for updating the project completion state where the state less than or equal to 90%. HQ updates the state above 90%.
NOTE 2 ββ DP vote comments and ST Audit comments are actually late comments on an FCD ballot and the Project Chair should determine the status according to whether such comments are to be addressed or deferred according to the SMPTE Standards Operations Manual.
6.2 Project States for ST, RP & EG documentsπ
- 0% - Project not approved (then project gets objections or is approved)
- 5% - Project awaiting ST objection disposition vote (then project is approved or cancelled)
- 10% - Project approved (then a document is created)
- 20% - WG or DG working on WD document (then WD is elevated to the TC)
- 25% - TC has WD document (then document starts pre-FCD review)
- 30% - WD to CD process i.e. pre-FCD review & register submission (then document ready for FCD ballot)
- 40% - CD awaiting FCD ballot (then FCD ballot starts)
- 50% - FCD ballot in progress (then FCD ballot ends)
- 60% - FCD ballot comment resolution (then pre-DP vote starts or ST audit starts)
- 70% - pre-DP review (then DP vote starts)
- 80% - DP vote (then ST Audit package delivered to HQ)
- 90% - ST Audit (then document sent for publishing)
- 95% - document in HQ (then document appears in store)
- 100% - published & document uploaded to TC Ref Docs
6.3 Project States for RDD documentsπ
- 0% - Project not approved (then project gets objections or is approved)
- 5% - Project awaiting ST objection disposition vote (then project is approved or cancelled)
- 10% - Project approved (then a document is created)
- 20% - WG or DG working on WD document (then WD is elevated to the TC)
- 25% - TC has WD document (then document starts pre-FCD review)
- 30% - WD to CD process i.e. pre-ballot review & register submission (then document ready for RDD ballot)
- 40% - CD awaiting RDD ballot (then RDD ballot starts)
- 50% - RDD ballot in progress (then RDD ballot ends)
- 60% - RDD ballot comment resolution (then ST Audit package delivered to HQ)
- 90% - ST Audit (then document sent for publishing)
- 95% - document in HQ (then document appears in store)
- 100% - published & document uploaded to TC Ref Docs
6.4 Project States for ER documentsπ
- 0% - Project not approved (then project gets objections or is approved)
- 5% - Project awaiting ST objection disposition vote (then project is approved or cancelled)
- 10% - Project approved (then a document is created)
- 20% - WG or DG working on WD document (then WD is elevated to the TC)
- 25% - TC has WD document (then document starts pre-FCD review)
- 30% - WD to CD process i.e. TC review (then document ready for SVP review)
- 40% - CD awaiting submission to SVP (then submitted to SVP)
- 80% - SVP review (then sent to HQ or returned to TC)
- 95% - document in HQ (then document appears in store)
- 100% - published & document uploaded to TC Ref Docs
6.5 Project States for TSP documentsπ
- 0% - Project not approved (then project gets objections or is approved)
- 5% - Project awaiting ST objection disposition vote (then project is approved or cancelled)
- 10% - Project approved (then a document is created)
- 20% - WG or DG working on WD document (then WD is elevated to the TC)
- 25% - TC has WD document (then document starts pre-FCD review)
- 30% - WD to CD process i.e. pre-FCD review & register submission (then document ready for SVP review)
- 40% - CD awaiting submission to SVP (then submitted to SVP)
- 80% - SVP review (then sent to HQ or returned to TC)
- 95% - document in HQ (then document appears on web)
- 100% - published & document uploaded to TC Ref Docs